Quote:
I didn't mean my (for shame) to be an excuse to turn this thread into an old discussion, but since I think the question is answered anyway...
Ditto. But since we're here, I recommend that newbies interested in a particular religion to pick a matching aura. (good/good, evil/evil, Ain/ordered, Marfik/chaotic, other gray/not extreme) It's not always necessary, but why make your life difficult?
Quote:
I don't think any of the lightie churches should except impure members. .... I think that a lot of good RP can come from non-dark members of darkie religions, but I haven't had enough experience in the darky camp to say whether this is fair to the darkie immortals.
If it can be good RP for grays to enter dark religions, why doesn't the same argument hold for light religions?
Sure, there are religions that are so linked to good and evil that a gray-aura character is manifestly silly. (Dulrik, Dabi, and so on.) Further, if following a god is going to betray one's alignment, it shouldn't be possible. For instance, I can't see an unprincipled character being untrustworthy enough to belong to Thuban.
But if the character's alignment allows him to seek the god, then the only other consideration should be whether the god is willing to accept the follower. That should be decided by the religion and the god on IC grounds, not some general rule on aura-matching.
Example: One Zavijite priest dismisses unprincipled characters as not having devotion enough to serve Zavijah's core values of knowledge and freedom. Another priest encourages the unprincipled to join the religion in hope of enlightening them, another of Zavijah's core values. Both should be valid interpetations, until the god and/or hierarchy decide otherwise.
There's a balance here. Roleplay prospers when priests can use a variety of ideas. At the same time, religions need boundaries to maintain unity and to encourage dramatic conflict. Yet when we must have strictures, let them at least flow from the IC roleplay of the god, instead of an arbitrary rule splitting philosophies into Team Good and Team Evil.
/end rant